Jewish Websites and Shabbos

The Wall Street Journal seems to like reporting on Orthodox Jews and e-commerce as it pertains to Shabbos. They had an article back in 2004 that quoted Rabbi Heinemann explaining all the details. It was an excellent piece that described the issues pretty well. At the time, Rabbi Heinemann ruled that people needed to close their shopping carts so that no business would take place on Shabbos. He apparently retracted the ruling (link to original article doesn’t seem to exist anymore, nor can I find the link to the relevant Kashrus Kurrents article).

Regardless, the Wall Street Journal published another article today about the subject:

For all its putative godlessness, the Internet abounds with religion; most major faiths have thousands of sites devoted to them. One run by the Eretz Hemdah Institute in Israel,, features an “Ask the Rabbi” service. We asked some questions about the Internet of Rabbi Yosef Carmel, dean of the institute and a rabbinic judge, educator and author.

* * *

What are some issues involving the Internet that an Orthodox Jew might be concerned with?


An Orthodox Jew who runs a business is supposed to close it on Saturday, the Sabbath. But what about a business on the Internet — a Web-site business? The answer is he doesn’t need to close his Web business on Saturday, and for two reasons. First, he isn’t doing anything, and thus he isn’t violating the Sabbath according to Jewish law. And second, on the Internet, it is not Sabbath for everyone in every place.



Why can you keep your Web-site business running, as long as you don’t work at the computer, but still have to close a physical business?


One of the most important things in Jewish law regarding Saturday is the atmosphere of Sabbath. If you are opening on the street your market or your store, that disturbs the spiritual atmosphere. If your Web site is working, it doesn’t disturb anything.


If you are an Orthodox Jew, you aren’t supposed to open your computer on the Sabbath. But you can leave it running because you are not doing anything on it and thus not violating the atmosphere of the special day.



What if you know there is a big game on Saturday, and you leave the monitor on to check the scores as you pass by?


You have no permission to look at it. Because it’s not the atmosphere you want for a Sabbath. You can ask the same question with a VCR, since you can set it to show a movie anytime you want.


Are there other special concerns with the Internet on the Sabbath?


Can a Jew in New York look at an Israeli Web site which was updated on Saturday, even if he is in New York and it is still Friday? No, because Jews must also not enjoy the work of another Jew on the Sabbath. So it is not permissible according to Jewish law to use an Israeli Web site that was updated on Saturday. If the Web site were somewhere else, and you knew for sure the workers were Jews, you would also have no permission to use it if it was updated on Saturday.


Do these answers represent the consensus of many rabbis?


Not many rabbis have dealt with these questions.


Are there things about their own holy days that other religions can learn from Judaism?


I don’t think Judaism wants others in the world to observe their own holy days according to Jewish law. But Jews would like non-Jews to take the values of the Sabbath and adapt them. To try to be more spiritual. To try to make a break in your everyday running of things. To try to think how you can be a good person, and do good things for others.

I guess I can’t look at Haaretz on Friday afternoon.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: